When the summer crowds have long gone, the leaf peepers have thinned, and the sidewalks are easy to navigate, we knowthe off-season is upon us on Nantucket. Our two Nantucket boutique hotels 21 Broad and 76 Main take a winter hiatus January through March, but now through the holidays is a great time to visit Nantucket. While many shops, bars, and restaurants close after the high season, many stay open for the 12,000 year-round residents and wintertime visitors. When visiting Nantucket during the off-season, here are our favorite places to eat year-round on Nantucket.
Dune | 20 Broad St, Nantucket | (508) 228-5550
Dune is a Lark favorite year-round because of its craft cocktails and fine dining cuisine that relies on seasonal, island-grown ingredients. The fall menu serves up comfort food like stews, braised meats, and seasonal vegetables like beets, mushrooms, and squash. Usually the wait for a table is considerable during the summer, so a visit to Dune in the off-season is a treat.
A Brotherhood of Thieves | 23 Broad St, Nantucket | (550) 228-2551
Located in the heart of Nantucket Town, this tavern is one of our favorite places to eat year-round on Nantucket. The basement bar dates back to the 1840s when it catered to the sailors of the island's vigorous whaling industry. With dark wood, a large fireplace, and a wide selection of craft beer, The Brotherhood is a great place to enjoy happy hour or a casual dinner.
B-ACK Yard BBQ | 20 Straight Wharf, Nantucket | (508) 228-0227
New in 2017, this barbecue joint serves up different regional styles of barbecue and has quickly become an island favorite. Classic barbecue meats like brisket and kielbasa are smoked on site, while the sides like lobster mac and cheese threaten to steal the show. A great selection of draft beer and creative cocktails make B-ACK Yard BBQ a great place to eat year-round on Nantucket.