The Penny Lane
Joining the Lark Hotels family in 2026, The Penny Lane welcomes you to a vintage Hamptons waterfront retreat, thoughtfully reimagined for the modern traveler. A sense of laid-back luxury infuses our 18-room property, blending classic beach-chic design with warm, experienced hospitality and modern amenities that make settling in feel effortless.
Mornings are slow and sunlit by Penny Pond. Afternoons filled with bike rides to uncrowded ocean beaches or lounging on the lawn or poolside. Evenings start with sunsets over the water, then down the street for the catch of the day fresh off local fishing boats, live music and soaking in the local flavors of the old-school Hamptons.
At The Penny Lane, we honor the landscape, the pace, and the people that shape Hampton Bays, creating a stay that feels welcoming, grounded, and refreshingly unforced.
Our Favorites
-
SUNSET DRINKS AT SUNDAYS
Settle in bayside as the sun dips low, cocktail in hand and live music drifting across the water. Order something fresh from the sea, linger longer than planned, and let the evening unfold at its own pace. It is the kind of night that feels effortlessly Hamptons.
-
STROLL PONQUOGUE BEACH AT GOLDEN HOUR
Wide open sand, ocean air, and one of the best sunset views in Hampton Bays. Take an easy walk along the shoreline, kick off your shoes, and let the sound of the waves do the rest. Simple, scenic, and exactly how a beach day should end.
-
BIKE IT OUT TO THE WATERFRONT
Hop on one of Penny Lane’s bikes and explore the neighborhood at your own pace. Cruise toward the waterfront, discover quiet side streets, or follow the breeze until you find your next stop. No plans needed, just an easy ride and plenty of time to wander.
OUR CAREFULLY CURATED GUIDE MADE JUST FOR YOU
Step out our front door and ease into the laid-back rhythm of Hampton Bays. Waterfront and unfussy. Local, yet lively. Beach-rooted, with just enough buzz. This corner of the Hamptons invites slow mornings, sun-soaked afternoons, and evenings that stretch effortlessly into night.